Thermal coffee makers: 6 models compared

BEST OVERALL
Breville Precision Brewer Pid with Pour Over

The ‘Breville Precision Brewer Pid with Pour Over’ is the best thermal coffee maker on the market. It has the versatility of both a drip and a pour over coffee maker. The built-quality is second-to-none, and the final product looks utterly beautiful.

It’s a high-end appliance that comes with a high-end price tag. But if it falls within your budget, it’s worth every penny.

Disclosure: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no additional costs to you.

BEST VALUE
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Thermal Coffee Maker

Despite having a dated appearance, the Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Thermal coffee maker is an excellent appliance for a relatively low cost, especially when you consider how expensive thermal coffee makers can be.

It has the Hamilton Beach ‘Two Ways to Brews’ system for extra versatility and is even K-Cup compatible for further convenience. Despite the brew time being slow(ish) this is still a great alternative to more expensive thermal coffee makers.

Disclosure: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no additional costs to you.

Coffee is a hot beverage, and coffee enthusiasts love their morning cup of Joe as hot as possible. Coffee makers with thermal carafes help maintain that heat in the liquid while simultaneously making the appliance more energy-efficient than products with warming plates.

Today, we’re going to look at our top six favorite thermal coffee makers, basing our opinions on ability, design, capacity, build quality, versatility, and value for money. 

Let’s get started.

1. Breville Precision Brewer Pid with Pour Over (BDC455BSS)

BEST Thermal coffee maker
Breville Precision Brewer Pid Temperature Control Thermal Coffee Maker w/ Pour Over Adapter Kit - BDC455BSS
  • Brushed stainless steel finished machine
  • Includes Pour Over Adapter; made from silicone shower head and plastic case
  • Thermo-coil heating and pump system with PID digital temperature control

Disclosure: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no additional costs to you.

Specifications

  • Genre: Thermal / Pour Over
  • Dimensions: 18.74 x 15.55 x 9.17 inches
  • Appliance Weight: 13.35lbs
  • Capacity:  12-Cup (60oz)
  • Material: Stainless Steel, Plastic
  • Available Colors: Stainless-Steel
  • Dishwasher Safe: No

Things To Love

  • Unrivaled Build-Quality: The heavy-duty build quality of the Breville Precision Brewer gives you confidence that this coffee maker will last for many years.
  • Superb Appearance: Produced with a high-quality brushed stainless-steel, a slick control panel, and sleek dials, this coffee maker is one of the best-looking appliances on the market.
  • Drip & Pour Capabilities: Complete with both drip and pour over coffee-making methods; the Precision Brewer offers enormous versatility.
  • PID Control: Proportional-Integral-Derivative. Or to the layperson, a device that maintains a more consistent water temperature than does a regular thermostat, resulting in a better cup of coffee.
  • Iced & Cold Coffee Features: You don’t have to go without coffee on a warm summer’s day thanks to these cold coffee brewing variants for a refreshing cold brew.
  • Gold Cup Standard: The ‘Gold Cup’ feature will automatically give you the precise settings recommended by the SCA (Specialty Coffee Association) to deliver the most delicious coffee possible.

What’s Not To Like?

  • It’s Expensive: It’s not just expensive, it’s really expensive. However, if you’re a coffee enthusiast with a disposable income, the quality of this appliance is worth the massive outlay.
  • It’s a Little Loud: The Breville Precision Brewer is a little louder than you would hope, not obnoxiously loud, but loud enough to notice.

Final Remarks

The Breville Precision Brewer Pid is so extensive that we can’t possibly fit all the information in the article. It’s quite simply the best thermal coffee maker on the market. It looks beautiful, feels well-made, and produces delicious and consistent coffee.

Overall Score: 19/20

2. Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Thermal Coffee Maker (49966)

Best VALUE Thermal coffee maker
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Thermal Coffee Maker, Single Serve & Full Pot, Compatible with K-Cup Pods or Grounds, Programmable, Black and Stainless (49966)
  • Two ways to brew: Brew a full pot using your favorite grounds on the thermal carafe side or make a cup for yourself using a Keurig k-cup pod or grounds on the single-serve side with this 2-in-1 coffee maker
  • Stainless steel, 10-cup thermal carafe: Thermal carafe keeps coffee hot and fresh. Features programmable timer, auto pause & serve and auto shutoff
  • Single-serve-brew with K-Cup pods or without: Pod holder and single-serve grounds basket are included. Features cup rest that adjusts to fit tall mugs and doubles as storage. Pod-piercing needle removes for easy cleaning to prevent clogging

Disclosure: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no additional costs to you.

Specifications

  • Genre: Thermal
  • Dimensions: 13.6 x 14.5 x 15.13 inches
  • Appliance Weight: 8lbs
  • Capacity:  10-Cup
  • Material: Plastic
  • Available Colors: Black – Black & Stainless – Black & Silver – White
  • Dishwasher Safe: Selected Parts

Things To Love

  • 12-Cup or Single Serve Options: The Hamilton Beach FlexBrew has two separate sides to brew either a full carafe or single-serve portions directly into a travel mug. You can not run these features simultaneously.
  • K-Cup Compatible: You’re not limited to using loose coffee grounds on the single-serve side, as this coffee maker is compatible with K-Cups.
  • Programmable Timer: Choose precisely when your coffee is brewed over a 24-hour period with the programmable timer.
  • Removable Drip Tray & Storage: Not only is the drip tray removable, which makes it easier to clean, but the top also comes off so you can store the single-brew basket or a K-Cup or two inside.
  • Intuitive Control Panel: Operating this coffee maker is super simple as the control panel was designed to be as intuitive as possible.
  • Pause & Serve: The pause and serve feature on the Flexbrew stops the brew cycle when you remove the carafe and starts again once it’s been replaced, so you can grab a sneaky coffee before the brew cycle has finished.

What’s Not To Like?

  • Looks Dated: Hamilton Beach has taken the retro approach with this coffee maker, and while that may appeal to some consumers, we feel there are better-looking appliances out there.
  • Slow-ish Brew Time: It’s not a huge concern; however, it is worth noting that the brew time on this coffee maker is a little slower than we would have liked.
  • No Filter Provided for the Carafe Side: Many brands supply permanent filters with their coffee makers these days. Unfortunately, there isn’t one with the FlexBrew.

Final Remarks

The Hamilton Beach BrewFlex coffee maker with two way brewing gives you the option of brewing into the thermal carafe or directly into a travel mug if you’re in a rush. It’s straightforward to use and brews delicious coffee. Also, it’s relatively inexpensive for a thermal coffee maker. So, if you don’t mind an appliance with a more retro feel, this one is worth considering.

Overall Score: 16.5/20

3. Ninja Hot & Cold Auto IQ Thermal Coffee Maker

Sale 13%
Ninja Hot and Cold Brewed System, Auto-iQ Tea and Coffee Maker with 6 Brew Sizes, 5 Brew Styles, Frother, Coffee & Tea Baskets with Thermal Carafe (CP307)
  • Coffee and tea brew settings: Brewing technology offers an array of coffee and tea options
  • Cold brew coffee and tea: Brew over ice at a lower temperature for smooth, naturally sweet flavor in 10 to 15 minutes
  • Smart basket recognition: System recognizes basket and displays coffee or tea drink options

Disclosure: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no additional costs to you.

Specifications

  • Genre: Drip
  • Dimensions: 11.81 x 10.01 x 15 inches
  • Appliance Weight: 11.09lbs
  • Capacity:  50oz
  • Material: Stainless Steel, Plastic, Rubber
  • Available Colors: Black
  • Dishwasher Safe: Selected Parts

Things To Love

  • It’s So Versatile: The Hot & Cold Auto IQ isn’t just a coffee maker; it makes tea, cold brew, iced tea.
  • Separate Brew Baskets: This Ninja appliance has separate baskets/filters for tea and coffee as not to contaminate flavors of one or the other.
  • Built-in Milk Frother: Brew multiple coffee styles with the aid of the built-in, fold away milk frother that will quickly provide creamy, sweet-tasting milk.
  • Drip Stop: Pause the brew cycle to pour yourself a cup without dripping coffee everywhere with the ‘Drip Stop’ button.
  • Smart Basket Recognition:  The Ninja Hot & Cold instantly recognizes whether you’re about to brew tea or coffee and alters the settings accordingly.

What’s Not To Like?

  • Relatively Expensive: In the grand scheme of things, this coffee maker is good value for money considering all the different features and functions; however, if you’re only interested in the thermal aspect of this machine, it’s a little pricey.
  • Slow(ish) Brew Time: While it isn’t frustratingly slow, it’s slower to brew than other similarly priced appliances on the market.
  • The Carafe Is Difficult to Clean: The carafe isn’t dishwasher safe, so you’ll need to clean it by hand. Unfortunately, the carafe’s opening is too small to fit your hand in, so a bottle brush or cleaning receptacle will be required.

Final Remarks

While the Ninja Hot & Cold Auto IQ Thermal Coffee Maker is expensive, it’s not Breville Precision Brewer levels of expensive. When you consider how versatile this appliance is, it’s worth the money if you have it.

However, it’s more of a kitchen multi-tool than a dedicated coffee maker, so it’s more suited to families than coffee enthusiasts. 

Overall Score: 17.5/20

4. Cuisinart Stainless-Steel Thermal 12-Cup Coffee Maker (DCC-3400P1)

Sale 20%
Cuisinart Stainless Steel Thermal Coffeemaker, 12 Cup Carafe, Silver
  • Hotter Coffee with expert coffee-making technology to ensure hotter Coffee temperature without sacrificing flavor or quality. Cord length : 36 Inches
  • Brew strength control allows you to select regular or bold Coffee flavor
  • Fully automatic with 24-hour Programmability, self clean, 1-4 cup setting, auto-off, and optional ready alert tone

Disclosure: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no additional costs to you.

Specifications

  • Genre: Thermal
  • Dimensions: 9 x 7.75 x 14.25 inches
  • Appliance Weight: 10.2lbs
  • Capacity:  12-Cup
  • Material: Stainless Steel, Plastic
  • Available Colors: Stainless Steel
  • Dishwasher Safe: Selected Parts

Things To Love

  • Attractive Stainless-Steel Exterior: This coffee maker has a wonderfully sleek appearance, accentuated by a quality stainless-steel exterior.
  • Brew Strength Control: This Cuisinart Thermal coffee maker allows you to choose between regular strength coffee and a bolder, more robust brew.
  • Cleaning Notification: You receive a warning notification from this appliance when it’s time to decalcify your machine. Regular maintenance will increase the appliance’s longevity.
  • Brew Smaller Batches: This appliance has a ‘1-to-4’ cup setting to brew smaller batches without losing your consistent flavor.
  • Charcoal Water Filter: You’ll get a smoother tasting, healthier cup of coffee thanks to the built-in water filter that gets rid of any impurities in your water.

What’s Not To Like?

  • Slow Pouring Carafe: If you’re the impatient type, you might get frustrated with how slowly the thermal carafe pours. Especially if you use it to fill the reservoir.
  • No Content Indication: There’s no way to know how much coffee is in the carafe without removing the lid.
  • Super Loud Notifications: The notification beeps are almost deafening, and there’s no way to turn the volume down.
  • Tiny Display: The LCD on the control panel is so small you’ll struggle to read it, especially if you wear glasses.

Final Remarks

Despite a few minor annoyances with the Cuisinart Stainless-Steel Thermal coffee maker, it still delivers delicious coffee for a decent price point. It is more expensive than the Hamilton Beach FlexBrew, but it’s much more attractive.

Overall Score: 16.5/20

5. Bunn Speed Brew Platinum Thermal Coffee Maker

Sale 14%
BUNN CSB3T Speed Brew Platinum Thermal Coffee Maker
  • Brews a full pot of coffee in less than half the time of other top selling home coffee makers
  • Commercial grade stainless steel hot water tank. Care & cleaning: Dishwasher-safe parts
  • Brews one large travel mug (20 ounce) to a full pot (50 ounce)

Disclosure: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no additional costs to you.

Specifications

  • Genre: Thermal
  • Dimensions: 13.9 x 8.3 x 14.9 inches
  • Appliance Weight: 8.4lbs
  • Capacity:  50oz
  • Material: Stainless Steel, Plastic
  • Available Colors: Stainless Steel
  • Dishwasher Safe: Selected Parts

Things To Love

  • Superb Appearance: This Bunn coffee maker is super attractive thanks to its unique appearance and the quality materials used to produce it.
  • Unique Showerhead: A specially designed showerhead ensures the Bunn Speed Brew delivers an even water distribution and excellent coffee extraction.
  • Simple to Use: Sometimes, less is more. The Speed Brew Platinum has very few features, but this simplicity is a joy to use.
  • Fast Brewing: Brew a full carafe of coffee in under 4 minutes. However, you have to be willing to leave the water tank left on continuously.

What’s Not To Like?

  • Complex Set-up & Water Tank: Setting up this coffee maker and filling it for brewing is confusing (for the first few times) and is one of the more bizarre systems we’ve ever come across.
  • Internal Hot Water Tank Needs To Be Left On: Bunn boasts that this coffee maker can make a full carafe in under 4 minutes. While this is technically true, it can only be achieved if the water tank is left switched on all the time, which is not energy efficient.

Final Remarks

The attractive Bunn Speed Brew Platinum Thermal coffee maker is an exercise in simplicity. If you don’t want to mess around with too many functions and features, this might be a good option for you. However, the initial set-up might be a bit confusing until you get the hang of it.

Overall Score: 15/20

6. Black + Decker 12-Cup Thermal Coffee Maker (CM2035B)

Sale 23%
BLACK+DECKER 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker, Black/Silver, CM2035B
  • 12-Cup Thermal Carafe - The large capacity carafe is double-walled and vacuum-sealed to keep your coffee at optimal drinking temperature for hours
  • Customizable Brewing Options - Drink your favorite coffee every morning using features like the brew strength selector and the option for small-batch (1-4 cup) brewing that maintains all the flavor of a full brew
  • Evenstream Showerhead - The Evenstream Showerhead dispenses water evenly over the packed coffee, extracting maximum flavor and wasting less

Disclosure: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no additional costs to you.

Specifications

  • Genre: Thermal
  • Dimensions: 8 x 11 x 11.5 inches
  • Appliance Weight: 4lbs
  • Capacity:  60oz
  • Material: Stainless Steel, Plastic
  • Available Colors: Stainless Steel
  • Dishwasher Safe: Selected Parts

Things To Love

  • Super Affordable: This Black + Decker coffee maker is the most affordable appliance we’ve looked at today. By Far.
  • ‘Evenstream’ Showerhead: This specially designed showerhead ensures an even distribution of water for maximum coffee extraction.
  • Auto Shut-Off: Black & Decker focus on safety with an auto shut-off feature just in case you forget to power down.
  • ‘QuickTouch’ Programming: Programming the timer and selecting various features is made super simple thanks to the quick touch programming on this thermal coffee maker.

What’s Not To Like?

  • No Filter Supplied: A large majority of home coffee makers come supplied with a permanent filter; unfortunately, this appliance does not, so you’ll be dependent on disposable ones.
  • The Button Text Wears Away: As time passes by, the text on the operational buttons will fade away, so you better learn what each button does as you go.
  • It’s Slow to Brew: This appliance is slow to brew, which is not surprising when you consider how cheap this coffee maker is.
  • The No-drip Pour Spout Drips: While Black + Decker claims the spout on this appliance is drip-free, many consumers report that this is not the case, and you should expect a little leakage.

Final Remarks

If you’re looking for a low budget appliance or are just getting into the world of coffee, the Black + Decker 12-Cup Thermal coffee maker is a low-risk option. If you can live with the mild annoyances that accompany cheap machines, it produces relatively decent coffee and is worth considering.

Overall Score: 14/20

Get Kitchen equipment deals

Subscribe to get our curated list of discounts on cookware and kitchen appliances as soon as sales start!