Ninja Foodi Grills: 3 models compared

Disclaimer: we may receive commissions from purchases made via our links at no cost to you

BEST OVERALL
Ninja FG551 Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill

The Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 is our favorite grill to come out of the Ninja models. It has six cooking settings (more than any other indoor grill of the workshop) and the largest capacity. If you are a single person, it is still worth it because the price is not that different from the rest, but the reviews regarding the performance are better.

Unlike the other two Ninja indoor grills in this blog, the Foodi Smart XL also includes a thermometer so you can ensure to customize the best temperature, according to your preferences.

1. Ninja FG551 Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill

Best Ninja foodi indoor grill
Ninja FG551 Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill with 4-Quart Air Fryer Roast Bake Dehydrate Broil and...
  • The Ninja FG551 Foodi Smart XL has six cooking functions. You can grill, air crisp, bake, roast, broil, and dehydrate.
  • It comes with a smart cook system that includes four protein settings and nine customizable doneness levels for you to enjoy your meat as desired.
  • It’s XL for a reason. You can fit up to six steaks at once!
  • The grill has a touch screen for easy use.
  • It includes a thermometer for better monitoring of temperature.

The Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-1 is a top-reviewed grill that, as its name suggests, comes with five extra functions. It grills, air crisps, bakes, roasts, broils and dehydrates your food. Even though it has a large interior for family-sized meals, it will fit on any countertop (15.7 L x 16.54 W x 11.05 H). Customers love its stainless steel and black design, and the cooking results for every meal. There are very few negative comments about it, but a few customers stated that it is quite expensive and that it has too many components to be washed after every use (although they are dishwasher-safe).

Pros

  • Large capacity
  • Versatile
  • Smart cook system
  • Smoke control system
  • Fits on any countertop
  • Stylish design
  • Integrated thermometer

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Too many parts to clean

Specifications

  • Dimensions – 15.7 L x 16.54 W x 11.05 H
  • Material – Stainless steel
  • Weight – 22.44 Pounds
  • Grill surface area – 108 square inches
  • Colors – Black and stainless steel finish
  • Dishwasher safe – Dishwasher safe parts.
  • Wattage – 1760
  • Smoke free – Yes

Size and Design

The Ninja Foodi Smart XL has a very modern design. It is stainless and black for a stylish look and some minor details in red in the front panel, on the touch screen.

You can cook up to 2lbs of fries at once, 24 hotdogs, or up to six steaks. It is ideal for family-sized meals and for cooking the mains and sides at the same time.

Score: 5/5

Features

  • Digital-display – It has a digital screen to control the settings that customers enjoy greatly.
  • Nonstick coating – You can cook bigger meals, and they won’t stick!
  • Integrated thermometer – Users have remarked that they no longer overcook or undercook their meals thanks to the thermometer.
  • Many cooking options – Probably one of the best perks of the grill is that it comes with five more settings to cook your meal.
  • Cyclonic grilling technology – Thanks to the 500F cyclonic air and the 500F grill grate, you will have a super tasty meal.
  • Smoke control system – It is smoke-free due to a temperature-controlled grill grate and a cool-air zone.

Score: 5/5

Performance and Cleaning

The grill has a touch screen that is easy to clean and saves you the hassle of sticky handles. You can remove its parts and wash them in the dishwasher, although according to some users, it can be a bit of a hassle to do this after every use. As for the exterior, it is as simple as wiping it.

The performance has excellent reviews. Customers can choose between four smart protein settings (beef, poultry, pork, and seafood) and obtain evenly cooked meals.

Score: 4/5

Should you buy the Ninja Foodi FG551 Smart XL?

The majority of consumers are extremely happy with the purchase of this product. It looks nice in the kitchen, it has a great capacity, and it is versatile for every person’s desired doneness. Sure, it is pricey; however, when you consider all of its functions, it is worth the investment.

If you have a large family and can afford it, you won’t be sorry.

Overall Score: 14/15 

2. Ninja Foodi AG301 5-1 Indoor Grill

Sale 13%
Ninja Foodi AG301 5-in-1 Indoor Electric Countertop Grill with 4-Quart Air Fryer, Roast, Bake,...
  • The Ninja Foodi Grill. The grill that sears, sizzles, and air fry crisps. Indoor grill and air fryer
  • 500F air circulates around food for amazing Surround Searing while the 500F high-density grill grate creates char-grilled marks and flavors, for food that's perfectly cooked on the inside and char-grilled on every side with Cyclonic Grilling Technology
  • With the BTU cooking power of an outdoor grill, it brings outdoor grill flavors conveniently to your countertop any day of the year

The Ninja Foodi 5-1 Indoor Grill is a versatile product with five different cooking settings, such as grill, air crisp, bake, roast, and dehydrate. It has a cyclonic grilling technology that delivers grill marks and char flavors like an outdoor grill, and the customers love its stylish design. The item comes with a cooking pot, air crisper basket, grill grate, and a recipe book. On the downside, there is some negative feedback regarding the virtually smoke-free function.

Pros

  • Many cooking functions
  • Cyclonic grilling technology
  • Nice design
  • Cooks evenly
  • PTFE/PFOA-free nonstick coating

Cons

  • It sets the smoke alarms off
  • A strong smell after its use

Specifications

  • Dimensions – 17 L x 14 W x 11 H
  • Material – Stainless steel
  • Weight – 14.5 Pounds
  • Grill surface area –10 x 10 inches
  • Colors – Black and silver
  • Dishwasher safe – The interior pieces are dishwasher safe
  • Wattage – 1760
  • Smoke-free – Yes

Size and Design

The Ninja Foodi 5-1 is black with a stainless finish, and the design is very sturdy. Its dimensions are 17 L x 14 W x 11 H; therefore, it will take some space out of your countertop, but if you have a big one, it won’t be a problem.

According to the features, you can cook up to four 8-ounce burgers or four 7-ounce chicken breasts at once; however, some users have stated that the cooking area fits two to three burgers, instead of four.

Score: 3.5/5

Features

  • Front panel – It has a digital screen to select the cooking mode.
  • High-density coating – The grill surface is nonstick and sturdy.
  • Many uses – You can choose among air crisp, grill, roast, bake, and dehydrate.
  • Cyclonic grilling technology – It delivers 500F cyclonic air for perfect char-grilled results.
  • Smoke-free system– Even though the grill is smoke-free, this function has mixed reviews.

Score: 4/5

Performance and Cleaning

The grill has a front panel for easy use, where you can select among five cooking settings. Most buyers have stated that all five functions work excellently, and the air crisp mode has much positive feedback. However, there is negative feedback regarding the odor after cooking. Some users have pointed out that after cooking, there is a greasy smell in the house

Regarding the virtually smoke-free function, there are controversial opinions. Some users have stated that it does not smoke, while others have remarked that the grill sets smoke alarms off as soon as it’s preheating.

Cleaning the product is simple, as the interior parts are removable and dishwasher safe.

Score: 3/5

Should you buy the Ninja Foodi 5-1 AG301?

The Ninja Foodi 5-1 AG301 is a well-reviewed grill with diverse functions to cook your favorite meals. The design is beautiful, and it is easy to use and clean. Nevertheless, there are some negative comments about a burning smell after using it, and about the virtually smoke-free functions, which many people describe as not smoke-free. We suggest investing a little bit more and purchase the Ninja Foodi 6-1 Smart XL.

Overall score: 10.5/15

3. Ninja Foodi Pro 5-1 AG400 Indoor Grill

Ninja Foodi Pro 5-in-1 Indoor Integrated Smart Probe, 4-Quart Air Fryer, Roast, Bake, Dehydrate, an...
  • Five cooking functions – grill, air crisp, roast, bake, and dehydrate.
  • Cyclonic grilling technology – it heats up to 500°F, and the air circulates for the perfect sear.
  • Dishwasher safe – the interior components are all dishwasher safe.
  • Nonstick coating – PTFE/PFOA-free ceramic coated grilling surface.
  • Recipe-book – it includes many recipes for you and your loved ones.
  • Superhot Grilling Technology – The combination of 500° F cyclonic air and 500° F high-density grill grate creates char-grilled marks and tasty flavors.
  • Integrated smart probe – You can stop worrying about undercooking or overcooking thanks to the smart probe that will monitor your food and alert you when it’s ready.
  • Smoke-free – The smoke control technology will control the temperature of the grill grate and keep the smoke out of the kitchen with its cool-air zone.
  • Intuitive digital display – You may choose among the five cooking functions, such as grill, air crisp, dehydrate, roast, and bake.
  • Ceramic-coated grill grate – It is PTFE/PFOA-free for a safe cook, and you can remove it.

The Ninja Foodi Pro 5-1 AG400 is also a versatile grill with five cooking settings. You can grill, air fry, bake, roast, and dehydrate your food. It has an integrated smart probe that monitors your food and lets you know when it’s perfectly cooked; therefore, you won’t struggle with overcooking or undercooking it. It is also virtually smoke-free, and it comes with a recipe book. On the downside, many customers have stated that it has a learning curve and that it does not come with all the accessories when you buy through Amazon.

Pros

  • Five cooking settings
  • Intuitive digital screen
  • Integrated smart probe
  • Smoke-free
  • PTFE/PFOA-free ceramic coating

Cons

  • Learning curve
  • Noisy
  • It does not include the accessories

Specifications

  • Dimensions – 17 x 14 W x 11 H
  • Material – Stainless Steel, ceramic
  • Weight – 24 Pounds
  • Grill surface area – 10 x 10 inches
  • Colors – Black and stainless steel finish
  • Dishwasher safe – Interior parts are dishwasher safe
  • Wattage – 1760
  • Smoke-free – Yes  

Size and Design

The Ninja Foodi Pro 5-1 grill has the same design as the Ninja AG301. It is black with a stainless finish, and the dimensions are 17 L x 14 W x 11 H. There are mixed reviews regarding the capacity; some users have stated that they wish the grill would have more capacity, while others are happy with fitting up to four 8-ounce burgers at once. If you have a large family, the XL model might be a better option for you.

Score: 4/5

Features

  • Nonstick coating – The grill has a ceramic coating in which your food won’t stick.
  • Multi-purpose – Choose your favorite cooking function, such as grill, dehydrate, air fry, and more.
  • Perfect cooking results – The integrated smart probe monitors the temperature for an even cook.
  • Virtually smoke-free – Keep the smoke away from the kitchen with this feature.

Score: 4/5

Performance and Cleaning

Even though it has a screen to select your cooking preferences, many customers have remarked that it takes some time to get used to; besides, it doesn’t come with an instructions manual, and it has some negative comments about the noise it makes. Nevertheless, the majority of users have mentioned that once you learn how to use it, the performance is excellent.

Regarding the cleaning, you can wipe the exterior and wash the accessories in the dishwasher.

Score: 3/5

Should you buy the Ninja Foodi Pro AG400?

The Ninja Foodi Pro 5-1 AG400 will deliver evenly cooked meals, and you will be able to choose among its many functions depending on your doneness preferences. It looks stylish on the countertop, and you can grill up to four burgers; however, there is negative feedback regarding the noise and learning curve. Some users have pointed out that there is no manual to get used to it and that it is a loud appliance.

If the Ninja XL is too large for your needs, you may invest in this grill if the noise is not a problem for you. Sure, it has a learning curve, but once you pass it, it is worth the purchase.

Overall score: 12/15

Scroll to Top
Get Kitchen equipment deals

Subscribe to get our curated list of discounts on cookware and kitchen appliances as soon as sales start!