5 Best Breville Toaster Ovens Compared

BEST BREVILLE TOASTER OVEN
Breville BOV900BSS

Breville BOV900BSSUSC is definitely the one to get if you like to entertain or have a big family, being the largest of all the toaster ovens by Breville.

It has more options than any other, such as the air frying and dehydrating mode.

Many users have found it so easy to use that they didn’t have the need to check the instructions manual, all of this is thanks to the large LCD screen it contains.

One of the downsides is that it is a pricey machine however, for the size and the versatility, we believe it is worth it.

Breville is a well-known Australian cookware brand. They offer a variety of toasters and toaster ovens, with different characteristics. Which one is best for you might be difficult to determine. Here are the five toaster ovens offered by Breville and how they compare between each other.

Breville toaster oven reviews

1. Breville BOV900BSS

BEST BREVILLE TOASTER OVEN
Breville BOV900BSS Convection and Air Fry Smart Oven Air, Brushed Stainless Steel
  • Super Convection Technology: 2 speed convection fan (Super & regular) offers greater cooking control. Super convection provides a greater volume of air to ensure fast and even heat distribution, perfect for air frying, dehydration and roasting
  • Precision Cooking & Element IQ: With Element IQ 6 Independent quartz heating elements move the power where it's needed most, above and below the food for perfect results
  • Air Fry & Dehydrate Presets: Why buy a stand alone air fryer or dehydrator when the Smart Oven Air can air fry french fries and other family favorites and dehydrate a range of foods; Dehydrate up to 4 trays of goodness

Things to love:

  • Large capacity: Perfect for family gatherings and holidays. This model offers the largest inside space in all of the brand´s toaster ovens. It can fit a large size turkey for roasting, and broil a 10 x 12 inches casserole. It also has the capacity to hold 4 dehydrating trays at the same time or baking more than 10 muffins. It can easily replace a full-size oven.
  • LCD Display: One of the biggest advantages it has on other brands has to be the LCD display that shows you all the 13 cooking options it offers, the temperature, the remaining cooking time, and the cooking phase in just one glance. These control features make it extremely easy, yet very sophisticated.
  • Versatility: More options than an average toaster oven in the market. You can choose between roast, broil, toast, air fry, dehydrate, and eight more pre-set functions. The convection cooking option is actually revolutionary because you can regulate the amount of air used when air frying or dehydrating for more uniformed cooking. This option is what the brand calls “Super Convection”, which is only available for this model.
  • Element IQ: This model comes with the Element IQ 6 technology, which consists of 6 individual quartz elements built-in on the top and the bottom of the unit. This aids in giving precise results when grilling or roasting.

What’s not to like?

  • Restrictions on food: Unlike many options in the market, this unit specifically has a sign that states “Do not use with foods that drip while cooking”, which a few of the users were disappointed about. These limits its use when it comes to different food options that may drip over a removable tray at the bottom of the oven.
  • Gets very hot while cooking: The second more recurrent critique on this model is that it gets really hot while using, which can be potentially dangerous in a family with children or curious pets. Besides, it warms up space around it, making it very uncomfortable during the summer.
  • Price: This model is more expensive than the average, which can make it unaffordable to some users.

Final Remarks

This unit is definitely the one to get if you like to entertain or have a big family, being the largest of all the toaster ovens by Breville. It is also the more sophisticated and has more options than any other, such as the air frying and dehydrating mode. On the other hand, many users have found it so easy to use that they didn’t have the need to check the instructions manual, all of this is thanks to the large LCD screen it contains. One of the downsides is that it is a pricey machine considering similar ones by other brands; however, for the size and the versatility, we believe it is worth it. 

Our score: 4.6 out of 5

2. Breville BOV800XL

CHEAPER ALTERNATIVE
Sale 10%
Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven 1800-Watt Convection Toaster Oven with Element IQ, Silver
  • Element IQ delivers the right power at the right time and when adjusted to taste, remembers
  • 9 present functions: Toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat and warm. Voltage: 110 to 120 Volts
  • 1800 Watts with 5 quartz heating elements. Capacity: 6 Slice Toaster, 13 inch Inch Pizza. Voltage 110 120 Volts

Things to love:

  • Convection powered: A powerful fan is built in this model in order to ease the cooking process by removing the cold air in your food and maintain the correct temperature inside the oven.
  • Easy to clean: The oven walls have a non-stick coating that allows you to cook anything without the fear of needing to scrub later. The outside is made with brushed stainless steel that gives it a nice timeless look.
  • Nine cooking functions: This model offers nine pre-set options such as bake, toast, bagel, broil, and reheat. Therefore, this unit can replace a conventional oven, microwave, and toaster, all in one.
  • Includes accessories: There is no need to buy special utensils to fit the size of this appliance since it comes with a baking pan, broil rack, and pizza pan; all-fitting for the three rack positions.

What’s not to like?

  • Does not include air-frying mode: Although it contains a convection fan that keeps the air on the inside circulating, this model doesn’t include air frying nor dehydrating mode such as the Smart Oven Air. Actually, this model is the Smart Oven Pro´s predecessor, which explains why it has fewer cooking options.
  • Doesn´t have interior light: Unlike the Smart Oven Air, this unit does not include an interior light for regular checking. Hence, it is hard to see when the meal is fully cooked without opening the oven´s door.
  • Durability of the knobs: Some users stated problems with the durability of the knobs, which break after 2 or three years of use.

Final Remarks

The Smart Oven by Breville is definitely one powerful machine that can achieve many functions in just one appliance. The positive reviews point out that the results are optimal, the meals are cooked evenly and this unit can fit everyday use. On the other side, technology has reached more levels since this model came out, such as air frying and dehydrating options. Besides that, this is a good option for replacing a full-size oven.

Our score: 4.2 out of 5

3. Breville BOV450XL

BEST BUDGET BREVILLE OVEN
Sale 24%
Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven with Element IQ
  • Smart element IQ: There’s heat, and there’s smart heat; Element IQ transfers heat intelligently across 4 quartz elements for precise and stable heat where and when you want it for perfect results, every time; Super fast 1800 Watt preheat gets your meals on the table more quickly
  • 8 cooking functions: 8 cooking functions to guide you to perfection: Bagel, toast, bake, broil, pizza, roast, cookies, and reheat
  • Not so mini capacity: Your mini smart oven fits 4 not so mini slices of toast, cookies, tuna melts and 11 inch pizzas

Things to love:

  • Super compact design: Perfectly engineered to fit the necessities of a couple or a single person. In addition, this size allows versatility for small kitchens or less space on the countertop.
  • Element iQ: Although smaller, this model contains one of the cooking pillars of Breville: the Element iQ technology, which allows more precision for the different cooking options through 4 quartz heating elements.
  • Capacity: 3 racks for different uses allow you to broil on the upper, toast and make pizza on the one in the middle, and bake and roast on the lowest. Its “not so mini” size fits 11-inch casseroles or trays for cookies.
  • Less electricity consumption: Because of its size, your electrical bill will be reduced since it takes less time to pre-heat, hence, less energy needed.

What’s not to like?

  • Unstable tray rack: Since the rack does not contain a safety lock or a mechanism to stay in place, it can easily come out when you are pulling the tray or the pan that contains the food. This was one of the things users disliked the most.
  • Reaches high temperatures on the outside: The surface can be very hot, which caused burns in some of the users.
  • Doesn’t make a beeping sound when done: Unlike usual small ovens or microwaves, this model doesn’t make any beep sound when the cooking process is over; however, the light on the screen changes from orange to blue when the cycle selected is complete.
  • Issues with toasting mode: Some users have found it to be very difficult to achieve an even toasting result, which is a big problem since this is one of the most used functions of a mini oven.

Final Remarks

Comparing this model to any other Smart Oven by Breville, we found this one to be suited for the smallest kitchens and everyday non-complicated uses. Especially college students and people with busy lives get great use of this appliance.

Given the fact that this does not contain a convection fan, the issue with uniformity when cooking gets worse, so it limits some uses you can get with the bigger models. The hot surface is something to consider if there are small children in the house. However, the majority of the users seemed very happy with the purchase.

Our score: 4.2 out of 5

5. Breville BOV845BSS

Sale 20%
Breville BOV845BSS Smart Oven Pro 1800 W Convection Toaster Oven with Element IQ, Brushed Stainless Steel
  • Features an interior oven light to keep an eye on your cooking
  • 10 pre set cooking functions include: Toast 6 slices, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat, warm, slow cook
  • Capacity: 6 slice toaster, 13 inches pizza. Dimensions-18.5 x 14.5 x 11 inches

Things to love:

  • Many cooking options: This model offers up to 10 different pre-set functions for cooking, such as toast, bake, roast, broil, and slow cook. The toasting option gives you a seven-level range between light and very dark toast.
  • Capacity: This is the smaller version of the Breville Smart Oven Air, which can hold up to 9 toasts at a time while the Smart Oven Pro can fit 6. Therefore, it’s perfect for everyday use in a small to medium family. This model does not take too much countertop space; also, the size helps to cook the meals faster than a large oven.
  • Stylish outside look: If you want to give a pop of color to your kitchen! This model is by far the most fun since it comes in three different colors: black sesame, cranberry red, and the original stainless steel.
  • Smart Element iQ: This new technology for heating up intelligently contains five quartz elements that activate separately according to the mode of cooking selected, which is adequate for specific results.
  • Easy to use: Thanks to the LCD display you can control the whole oven, know the remaining cooking time, and the intensity and the temperature.

What’s not to like?

  • Defects on the convection system: The great majority of the negative reviews come from users that stated problems with the convection option since apparently, the fan stopped working after just a few months of use. Usually, this incident, accordingly with users, comes after hearing really loud noises coming from the convection fan.
  • Software error: Several users said that a computer error was shown on the first attempt to use. This error doesn´t allow the machine to work in any way. According to the Breville customer service, it seems to be due to electric failure.
  • Weak door glass: A handful of reviews stated that the glass on the door shattered during use after reaching very high temperatures on modes like pizza.

Final Remarks

The Smart Oven Pro is the smaller version of the full-size Smart Oven Air that is already one of the most powerful toaster ovens of Breville. They share 10 of 13 cooking functions and the Smart Element iQ technology and even the commands and LCD screen that make it so easy to use. However, the price is very high given the number of critiques about the quality. Those are the reasons why we ranked this one as one of the lowest from the bunch.

Our score: 3.7 out of 5

6. Breville BOV650XL

Sale 39%
Breville the Compact Smart Oven, Countertop Electric Toaster Oven BOV650XL
  • Smart element IQ: There’s heat, and there’s smart heat; Element IQ transfers heat intelligently across 4 quartz elements for accurate and stable heat just where and when you want it for perfect results, every time
  • 8 cooking functions: 8 cooking functions to guide you to perfection: Toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies and reheat
  • All the room for delicious you’re looking for: 4 Slice Toaster, 12 inches Pizza, 6 cup muffin tray, roast chicken and anything else you’ve got for it

Things to love:

  • Compact design: Without going all “mini oven”, this is the intermedium size between the Mini Smart Oven and the Smart Oven. It can fit 4 slices of bread or a 12-inch pizza.
  • 8 pre-set cooking functions: You can choose between toast, bagel, roast, broil, bake, pizza, reheat, and cookies.
  • Smart heat: Just like all the toaster ovens by Breville, this one also has Smart Element iQ technology through 4 quartz elements of individual heating, similar to the Mini Smart Oven.

What’s not to like?

  • No convection fan: For being just a few bucks less than the Smart Oven, this one does not have a convection fan that helps circulate the hot air on the inside of the unit. For the price, this is disappointing.
  • No interior light: For being a deep interior oven and not having much height, users stated that in order to check if the back of the food is fully cooked, they needed to pull the whole tray out, difficulting and interrupting the cycle.
  • Defects on fabrication: Several users posted reviews complaining about the reliability of this model. Some stated that it only worked for a few months before breaking, others got the “E01” software error just like the Smart Oven Pro.

Final Remarks

Out of all of the Breville toaster ovens, this one should be the one that fits the more amount of clients because of its compact and comfortable size.

However,  if we compare to its bigger version (which is not much more expensive) the difference between both pre-set options is abysmal since the convection cooking is lost in this model. Besides that, the quality defects appear recurrently in this unit. We recommend going bigger with the Smart Oven or going smaller with the Mini Smart because this one doesn’t seem to offer an advantage over any of them.

Our score: 3.5 out of 5

Quick Breville toaster oven comparison

BOV900BSS vs. BOV800XL, BOV845BSS, BOV450XL, BOV650XL

The 900BSSUSC has the largest inside space of all the models by Breville, with 1 cubic foot interior and a tray capable of holding up to 9 slices bread simultaneously; the second biggest is the 845BSS and the 800XL that fit 6 toasts, then the 650XL and 450XL that fit 4. The 900BSSUSC is the only one of all the ovens that offer dehydration mode and air frying with super convection. In summary, this model has all the pre-cooking options present on the other models. This is the most modern and professional out of the bunch. When it comes to price, it is about 30% more expensive than the second largest but it’s 40% bigger in size, which seems a deal more than fair.

BOV845BSS vs. BOV800XL, BOV450XL, BOV650XL

The 845BSS comes with 10 pre-set options for cooking vs. 9 programs offered by the 800XL, and 8 that the 450XL and the 650XL come with. The only difference between the functions is the slow-cooking option, only present in the 845BSS. When it comes to size, 800XL and 845BSS are very similar, since the 800XL is the 845BSS’s older version. When it comes to price, the 845BSS is just 1% more expensive than 800XL, which would have made it the obvious choice, of course. On the other hand, users have shown more acceptance to the older version since the 845BSS comes sometimes with issues on the convection system.

BOV800XL vs. BOV450XL, BOV650XL

Basically, the differences between the 800XL and the 650XL are about size, since the 650XL is a compact version of the 800XL. They differ on the number of quartz elements of the individual heat system, the 800XL having 5 and the other two have 4. On the functions side, the 800XL just offers one more option than the others, which is “warming”. Also, the pricing for the 800XL is 30% more than the 650XL and 40% more than the 450XL, but the reviews on the 450XL are much more positive than the 650XL, and the ones on the 800XL are even better. Therefore, it would be advisable to invest 30% more to get this model.

BOV450XL vs. BOV650XL

When it comes down to a variety of options, both models have 8 pre-set cooking configurations. The main difference between them is the size. The 650XL´s dimensions are 15”x17”x10” and the 450XL´s are 14.5”x16”x8”. Giving the difference you will be giving up 2 inches of height when choosing the 450XL over the 650XL. This space may be the decisive element that allows this appliance to fit in a small kitchen. On the other hand, the users have been preferring the 450XL over the 650XL by far, giving the fact that some defects in fabrication were seen in the 650XL.

Get Cookware deals

Subscribe to get our curated list of discounts on cookware and kitchen appliances as soon as sales start!